What gem identification actually is
Two stones that look identical can be a fine ruby and an ordinary garnet worth a tiny fraction of it. Colour, cut and clarity tell you almost nothing about species, because different minerals share the same appearance and the same mineral appears in many colours. Identification works the other way round: you measure physical constants that do not change with appearance — how much the stone bends light, how dense it is, how it behaves under polarised light — and eliminate everything those measurements rule out. You rarely "recognise" a stone. You narrow 132 candidates down to one.